An Americano is a type of black coffee: you make it by adding water to espresso, while black coffee means coffee you serve without milk or cream. If you're comparing an Americano with filter, drip or French press coffee, the main difference is how you brew it.
Is an Americano a type of black coffee?
Yes. Black coffee describes how you serve coffee, not a particular brewing method. You can drink espresso, an Americano, pour-over, drip coffee or French press coffee black.
To make an Americano, you combine espresso with water, usually hot water for a hot drink. You don't make a standard Americano by simply adding water to any brewed coffee.
On a café menu, “black coffee” may mean the house filter or batch-brewed coffee rather than an Americano. Ask which brewing method the café uses if the menu doesn't specify it. Also check what “filter coffee” means there, since the term can refer to a milk-based drink made with coffee decoction.
How do you make an Americano or brewed coffee?
For an Americano, you use an espresso machine to force hot water through a compact bed of finely ground coffee. You then dilute the small, concentrated shot with water. You extract the espresso first; the added water doesn't pass through the coffee grounds.
With other brewing methods, you use water to extract flavour from the grounds and produce the coffee you drink. Your grind size, brewing time and choice of filter all affect the result.
- Drip or pour-over: You pour water over ground coffee, or use a machine to dispense it. The water flows through the grounds and a filter into a cup or jug.
- French press: You steep the grounds in water, then press down a metal mesh plunger to separate most of them from the drink.
- Traditional coffee filter: You pour water over a bed of grounds to collect a decoction, which you can dilute with water to drink black.
Adding water to French press coffee gives you diluted French press coffee, not an Americano, because you haven't used espresso as the base.
How does an Americano taste compared with brewed coffee?
In an Americano, you can often still taste the character of the espresso after adding water. You may notice a roasted edge, a lingering aftertaste or some crema, the fine foam on freshly extracted espresso. Crema usually thins or breaks up when you add water.
With paper-filtered coffee, you'll generally notice a cleaner, lighter texture because the paper traps much of the oil and fine sediment. French press coffee usually feels fuller and may leave a little sediment in your cup because its metal mesh lets more fine particles through.
You won't necessarily find either drink more bitter, acidic or smooth. Your beans, roast level, grind and extraction can matter as much as the brewing method. A dark-roast filter coffee can taste more bitter than a well-made Americano using a lighter roast.
For a useful comparison, choose similar cup sizes and, where possible, the same beans. Otherwise, you may mistake a difference in roast or dilution for a difference between brewing methods.
Which has more caffeine?
Shot count and serving size matter more than the drink's name. You'll generally get more caffeine from an Americano with two espresso shots than from one with a single comparable shot, but a large brewed coffee may contain more caffeine than either.
Adding water to espresso reduces its concentration, not the total caffeine already in your cup. If you use the same double espresso to make either a small Americano or a larger one, you'll get roughly the same caffeine, provided you use the entire double shot.
Don't judge caffeine by bitterness, colour or how strong your drink tastes. The US Food and Drug Administration notes that caffeine content varies between products and serving sizes. Ask the café how many shots it uses and whether it has caffeine information, rather than assuming all cups contain the same amount.
Which should you order?
Choose an Americano if you like espresso's flavour but want a larger drink to sip. Ask for paper-filtered coffee if you prefer a cleaner texture, or French press if you enjoy a fuller mouthfeel.
Give the barista three details: your preferred cup size, whether you want it hot or iced, and how concentrated you like it. For an Americano, check the number of shots before asking for extra water. More water makes your drink milder without reducing its total caffeine.
If you want coffee without additions, say “no milk and no sugar”. Black coffee usually excludes milk and cream, but saying “black” alone doesn't always tell the barista whether you want sugar.
How to make an Americano or brewed black coffee at home
For an Americano, pull a single or double espresso and add hot water. Start with one part espresso to two parts water by volume, then adjust to taste. You can use this as a starting ratio, not a fixed rule.
If you don't have an espresso machine, you can use a moka pot to make concentrated coffee, then dilute it. You can make a satisfying black coffee this way, though it isn't technically an espresso-based Americano.
For brewed black coffee, start with about 15 g of ground coffee per 250 ml of water, then adjust to suit your brewer and taste. Use a medium grind for drip or pour-over and a coarser grind for French press. Change one variable at a time so you can tell what improved your cup.
For hot brewing, the National Coffee Association recommends water at approximately 90°C to 96°C. If your drink tastes harsh, check your grind, brewing time and equipment cleanliness rather than repeatedly adding water to mask the flavour.